12 Comments
User's avatar
Heidi Lynn Adelsman's avatar

John Mitchell sure was confused where was he from and how did he become an authority?

Expand full comment
Jill Swenson's avatar

A botanist and sickly physician from a wealthy Virginia family who went to London and there decided to draw his map to convince the British of the threat of French colonialists in the north. Not a professional map-maker but considered himself a geographer. Thanks for the question. I love these deep dives into maps, meaning and memory of place. Thanks for reading and restacking!

Expand full comment
Heidi Lynn Adelsman's avatar

“Considered himself a geographer,,,” being a botanist and doctor I guess he could do whatever he wanted. Never ceases to amaze me how much power and license these fellas asserted.

Expand full comment
Jill Swenson's avatar

Educated at Edinburgh University, he was born into power; the diploma gave him license, eh?

Expand full comment
Christopher Johnston's avatar

I like how you identified Elm Point on the map. I gave that quirk of map-making a supporting role in my novel. I'd love to hear what you might dig up about the history of that isolated patch of land that hangs off Buffalo Point, and how the US and Canada have treated it over the years.

Expand full comment
Jill Swenson's avatar

I might ask for assistance in that effort to learn more about that piece that hangs off Buffalo Point. I think I saw it is for sale and I am so curious! On the research trip list for when the ice melts in June.

Expand full comment
Deb Sinness's avatar

Fascinating Jill, I had no idea about that little chimney in Minnesota.

Expand full comment
Jill Swenson's avatar

I'm still trying to find out how it came to be called a "chimney" but that's what everyone in Minnesota referred to that shape on the map when I was a kid.

Expand full comment
Deb Sinness's avatar

Especially since it’s surrounded by water and Canada.

Expand full comment
Jill Swenson's avatar

I looked it up as a geographical term and it is considered a pene-exclave. Not an enclave, but related notion. The lake is the center of a whole community white settlers didn't consider in dividing up lands they "discovered."

Expand full comment
Deb Sinness's avatar

🙄

Expand full comment
Laura Jean Baker's avatar

The puzzle pieces of land have such complicated and inconsistent histories!

Expand full comment